Welcome to Alletto's Restaurant
Alletto's Restaurant, nestled in Lindenhurst, NY, is a cherished culinary gem celebrated for its family-style service and exceptional seafood offerings. This cozy, nautical-themed eatery exudes warmth, enhanced by a charming fireplace, making it an ideal spot for intimate dinners or special celebrations. Patrons rave about the Veal Marsala and succulent seafood samplers, which showcase the chef's dedication to flavorful, perfectly cooked dishes. Guests frequently praise the attentive staff, who foster a welcoming atmosphere reminiscent of home. With a rich history of delighting customers for over four decades, Alletto's continues to be a must-visit for locals and visitors alike.
-
218 E Montauk Hwy, Lindenhurst, NY 11757, United States Hotline: +1 631-226-9205
Welcome to Alletto's Restaurant, a beloved culinary gem nestled in the heart of Lindenhurst, New York. Located conveniently at 218 E Montauk Hwy, this family-run establishment has been serving the community with warmth and excellence for over four decades. Renowned for its varied menu that tantalizes the taste buds, Alletto's specializes in both classic Italian and seafood dishes, making it a perfect dining destination for any occasion.
As you enter the restaurant, you are greeted by a charmingly nautical decor that evokes a sense of coastal warmth, complemented by the inviting atmosphere created by a cozy fireplace. The layout seamlessly leads you into a welcoming bar area before guiding you to a peaceful dining space filled with 15 to 20 intimate tables. Reviews from patrons like Frank Lynch highlight the family-like service and quiet ambience—ideal for a romantic date night or a special family gathering.
One of the standout dishes that consistently garners praise is the Veal Marsala, beautifully prepared to perfection. Diners rave about the complimentary salad and freshly baked, hot sesame bread served alongside their meals, truly elevating the dining experience. A perfect example comes from Mary Koslap-Petraconp, who recalled enjoying a seafood sampler that included generous portions of clams, shrimp, mussels, and more, all cooked precisely right. Accompanied by gloriously tender linguine topped with garlic and oil, the meal is comforting and exquisite.
Another highlight is the whole lobster dish, which Stacey Jedlicka enjoyed for her father's birthday. The lobsters are served with a sense of care and attention to detail, making every meal at Alletto's a celebration of flavors. Not to forget, the homemade desserts are the cherry on top—because who doesn’t appreciate a sweet ending to a perfect meal?
While customer reviews emphasize the impressive service and cleanliness of the venue, it's the food that keeps patrons coming back for more. Coach Ray declares it the best steak around, and newcomers like jillanne burns find themselves making memories on special occasions, proving that Alletto's is more than just a restaurant—it’s a cornerstone of shared moments and cherished traditions.
With its delightful combination of atmosphere, service, and exquisite dishes that feel like they were crafted with love, Alletto's Restaurant invites you to indulge in a dining experience that leaves you craving more. Whether you reside in the area or are making a trip from afar, Alletto's promises to be a culinary destination that warms your heart and satisfies your palate.
For reservations or inquiries, feel free to call them at +1 631-226-9205. Your next favorite meal awaits at Alletto's!
This place is one of 2 places I have found on Long Island that makes Veal Marsala correctly. They start you off with a bowl of salad and different dressings. Then the bread... oh man. Hot and served with the salad. The staff made me feel like I was having dinner at a family members house. The atmosphere was quiet and seemed to have had my Playlist on shuffle. When you first walk in you walk directly into the bar. They bring you to the back to find 15 to 20 tables. The decor is nautical. Perfect place for a date night during the week. We ate like pigs and had a drink.
First time here and had a great experience. Staff was friendly and super kind, place was so beautiful & clean with a fireplace. Peaceful relaxing place. And the chef Tommy was amazing everything was perfect. Definitely recommend this place.
Where are all the Friday Date Night Dinner Goers??? This is the place to be at!!! Took my Dad for his Birthday on a Friday night and we both had whole 2lb lobsters cooked to perfection and cut for ease of eating. A hot sesame bread loaf and salad with dressing choices were delicious and included with the meal. Felt like we were served like family and the atmosphere was clean and cozy. Desserts were homemade and can bring home! Let's bring this family-run and long time running restaurant shine on the map! Would take the ride from my north shore home out to Alletto's anytime!
We spent Christmas Eve having dinner at the excellent Alletto's. What a treat. We had the seafood sampler special for 2 which included clams, shrimp, mussles, king crab legs and a losbter. Everything was perfectly cooked and it came w 2 bowls of linguine with garlic and oil and a large salad and freshly baked loaf of bread. The lovely dining room was warm and cozy with the fireplace adding to the festive atmosphere. We have been coming to Allettos for years and have never been disappointed. It is our favorite seafood restaurant.
Food and service are wonderful! We can’t believe there’s no line at the door. Try this place. Guaranteed you’ll love it.
I have lived two miles from Alletto's for 48 years and never ate there. For our 51 anniversary I wanted lobster and they did not disappoint! Everything was perfectly cooked and delicious. It's going to be a tradition now. Pics are before and after.
By far the best steak around these parts! With all that is wrong with the TOB (pot holes, high taxes, etc.) this place is a hidden gem. For any of you who haven't been there in a minute, it's time you rediscover this staple of our community. FOUR DECADES of service, are you kidding me! Great time, great food our crew will be there ONCE A MONTH for sure!
Hayley, our waitress was delightful. Our meal included the special for two people with whole lobster, shrimp, clams, crab legs, and muscles over linguine in garlic white sauce. Only issue I have is that the prices have gone up and the website still shows the old prices. In addition person who answered the phone when I called with questions could’ve been more friendly and amicable.